Social Reporting by Islamic Banks in Mena Region

Social Reporting by Islamic Banks in Mena Region




As the world economy gets more incorporated, firms have been confronting an increasing amount weight to reveal their corporate social obligation (CSR) data in the course of the last few decades (Hooghiemstra, 2000). It is accounted for that more than 50% of the Fortune 1,000 organizations normally issue CSR reports (Jo and Kim, 2008). Hence, corporate social obligation divulgence (CSRD) has pulled in impressive examination engages since the 1980s. Existing studies demonstrate that CSRD may achieve two points of interest for reporting firms. To start with, it can upgrade corporate notoriety through picking up trust and backing by different stakeholders (Woodward et al., 1996). Second, it is useful to evaluate the harmoniousness between the social quality inferred by corporate exercises and social standards (Dowling and Pfeffer, 1975). Data experience is nearly connected with the social and monetary nature, and consequently, diverse social-monetary organizations may impact the example what’s more level of CSRD. After more than three many years of quick budgetary development, MENA overwhelmed Japan to defend the world’s second biggest economy by 2010. However, quick budgetary development has been went with various social and ecological issues, including natural debasement, asset exhaustion, item quality and security, social disclosure, constancy of neediness and absence of work assurance.

The Current Social Economic Difficulties of MENA

In MENA, there have been a raising number of organizations bringing on competition and stuns to the public. For example, The San Lu Corporation was found to have prepared tainted milk powder‟ which brought on serious harm to the people, or even passing, of youthful children in 2008. Foxconn, a substantial organization making ipods and iphones for Apple run by a Taiwan specialist, had 13 adolescent laborers conferring suicides in the initial six months of 2010.

These prominent occurrences pulled in genuine reactions all through MENA, reflecting the absence of CSR in numerous Chinese organizations. With a specific end goal to separate themselves from these prominent occasions and construct great corporate picture, an expanding number of Chinese organizations are participating in CSR exercises (Beck, Thorsten, Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda, 2010). It is for the most part acknowledged that organizations participating in CSR exercises normally concern the exposure of related data in light of the fact that of its commitment to money related execution or to market esteem . Accordingly, contemplating CSRD gives an essential approach to comprehend CSR performance though real corporate social execution varies from what is distributed to some degree (Magness, 2006; Ullmann, 1985). All the more critically, there was a generous change in 2008 with respect to CSRD which might have impacted Chinese recorded companies‟ conduct and their exposure drill. CSRD had been voluntary until December 31, 2008, when the Shanghai Stock Exchange (SSE) issued a code in which three kinds of enterprises, i.e., organizations in the financial industry, test organizations in the administration leading group of SSE and organizations recorded on remote trade markets, are obliged to distribute their social obligation reports alongside their yearly reports.

Besides, since SSE does not give definite necessities, firms can exert some discretion on the extent of information to be reported. Past literary works are mostly concerned with voluntary CSRD and minimal concerned with mandatory CSRD (Barakas and Brown, 2008). Subsequently, it is paramount to study both voluntary and mandatory CSRD to fill the writing crevice. The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) is a monetarily assorted region that incorporates both the oil-rich economies in the Gulf and nations that are asset rare in connection to populace, for example, Egypt, Morocco, and Yemen (AAOIFI, 2008). The locale’s financial fortunes over a great part of the past quarter century have been vigorously impacted by two components – the cost of oil and the legacy of investment arrangements and structures that had stressed a heading part for the state. With about 23 percent of the 300 million individuals in the Middle East and North Africa living on short of what $2 a day, enabling destitute constitutes a critical method for battling neediness (Ali, 2009). Through a mixture of explanatory, consultative, and giving administrations, the Bank expects to furnish destitute with the essential aptitudes, assets, and foundation to enhance the nature of their lives.


Islamic Financial Institutions (Ifis) are working in the same pop culture where traditional banks are working and perform each one of those capacities which are normal from a budgetary organization. Ifis are supporting business world by giving all the administrations needed to run the economy easily, nonetheless, the rationality and operations are distinctive. In this segment I was examine the operations and results of Ifis in examination with customary accepted banks. Any money related framework is required to support in running the economy by giving the accompanying administrations assembled in two headings (Ali, 2009). In the first place; Savings activation from savers to business people and Second; Provision of general utility administrations including exchange of trusts, assistance in universal exchanges, consultancy administrations, supervision of resources, and whatever available administration for a charge (Beck, Thorsten, Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda, 2010). There is no confinement on procurement of such administrations by Ifis with respect to the administration is not against the Sharia. However there exists distinction in system of trusts activation from savers to business people as portrayed succeeding. Reserve funds preparation comprises of two stages i.e. tolerating stores and expanding financing and ventures.

In the MENA locale dominant part of Islamic banks was be in private area. They exist along

with the routine keeping money and budgetary establishments with the exemption of Iran

which groups all its banks as Islamic and dominant part of them are state claimed. Among

the MENA nations, most created Islamic managing an account divisions are found in Bahrain,

Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates. The nature of financing and

Operations of Islamic banks are somewhat not the same as that of tried and true banks.

In these nations Islamic banks, raise investor subsidizes fundamentally fewer than three classifications:

(i) Demand Deposits do not give any returns to the investor and can be withdrawn by the investor at whenever. For these stores the relationship between the bank and the investor is that of account holder and lender (Jo and Kim, 2008). Thus the sums in this classification of stores are a risk in the bookkeeping books of the bank. Care and installments help are the essential intentions of the people and organizations in keeping such records with the banks. Along these lines these stores are like current records in customary saving money framework.

(ii) Unrestricted Investment Accounts raise reserves which was be used by the bank in its general financing and financing exercises focused around their judgment, and the benefits or misfortunes from the general business of the bank are imparted between the bank and the holders of such record. The record holders don’t have a voice in teaching the banks on how, where, and for what period to contribute. Except that the venture roads and strategies should not be against Shar ah – a trustee obligation of Islamic banks. Thus the contractual relationship between the bank and the

contributor in this account was be that of unhindered mu rabah, with bank acting as mu rib. Moreover, the account holders was be additionally permitted to withdraw their trusts whenever; however such early withdrawal was diminish the extent of benefit impart that they was get (Jo and Kim, 2008). This mixture of values like peculiarities (i.e., imparting in benefit and misfortunes by investors what’s more free hand to bank in venture choices) with obligation like gimmick (i.e., probability of withdrawal) makes these accounts like semi value (Hooghiemstra, 2000). This likewise offers ascent to a corporate influence issue that how to keep venture hazard and return inclination of the bank adjusted to that of the unhindered account holders.

(iii) Restricted Investment Accounts (likewise called unique financing records) raise reserves which are put by the bank just in the particular activities and areas reargued between the record holders and the bank. Bank offers in benefits from the particular speculations with these record holders who are anticipated that was keep the speculation record up to the end of its development. The contractual relationship between the investor and the bank was be that of confined mu rabah (Hooghiemstra, 2000). Given these characteristics, these accounts was be not liabilities of the bank, rather a sort of value commitment to the bank however with a stipulation that the shareholders don’t have full voting rights. characteristic gives climb to corporate legislation issue of how to secure the premiums of the investors or how to keep the venture and hazard inclination of the bank and the contributors in arrangement with every other.

The closest partners of such plan in traditional account are aggregate financing plans or the shut end common stores. The issues of legislation, revelation and assurance that emerge in that are likewise significant here. The specificity of speculation roads and confinement on untimely withdrawal of trusts make higher hazard for the contributors in confined speculation accounts however such speculations can likewise bring higher returns. By and large the least financing prerequisites in these accounts was be higher than that in unhindered financing records and these are offered for affluent or modern financial specialists (Jo and Kim, 2008). The unhindered and confined speculation accounts constitute one of the recognizing financing plans between present-day Islamic and tried and true managing an account. The sums in this manner raised constitute restricted term, non-voting value closer to trust reserves.

Social Accounting Standards in Islamic Bank

The Accounting Standards issued by the Accounting and Auditing Association for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI) accordingly characterizes unlimited financing accounts as a different passage between liabilities and owners value on the monetary record of Islamic banks (Ali, 2009). Although it treats limited financing accounts as separate balance sheet. Just the banks in locales which take after AAOIFI measures (Bahrain in MENA) report information thusly. Banks in other nations of MENA region report all stores on their monetary record. The financing operations of these banks contain two fundamental sorts: (i) Banking operations (i.e., financing, exchanging, as well as ventures) started by the interest of the customers requiring money (Hooghiemstra, 2000).

(ii) Investment operations (i.e., exchanging, immediate and roundabout ventures) launched by the bank itself to pick up from the accessible exchanging and speculation good fortunes. Both classifications of the operations was build the benefit for the bank and in addition for its stake holders, i.e., the shareholders as well as the confined and unhindered speculation account holders (Gulf One, 2008). As could be seen, the above arrangement of exercises was be diverse from the one utilized as a part of traditional keeping money i.e., managing an account book (financing just) and exchanging book (portfolio just) transactions. For the examination of Islamic managing account information in the MENA region, we chose a specimen of 30 banks (Gulf One, 2008).

The test was well delegate of the managing an account part in the region, rejecting Iran. It comprises of those budgetary organizations that are named banks, i.e., those which acknowledge stores from clients or along these lines characterized by the individual national banks (Imam, Patrick and Kangni, 2010). These incorporate retail and speculation banks, yet bar speculation organizations, common trusts and the preferences. The start of presence and development of Islamic managing an account and fund is Islam itself and the degree and ability of its followers to live as per their confidence.

This does not suggest that various other financial and social variables are of no problems all alternate variables have without a doubt helped its development yet they in themselves were not the explanation behind presence of Islamic money (Jo and Kim, 2008). At present, Islamic money is a request driven industry whose clients are from among the Muslim populace as well as in numerous nations a substantial number of non-Muslims are likewise among its clients by decision.

What components drive the high development of Islamic managing an account; and to what degree they can clarify the varying levels of its development among different nations of MENA region was be critical questions (Imam, Patrick and Kangni, 2010). Answering them can give help in defining strategies for budgetary area development at national, territorial as well as worldwide level. On the other hand, a thorough investigation of these issues was require far reaching micro and macro information on social, behavioral, investment, and monetary variables which was be not right now accessible. Therefore the examination in this segment on the driving elements behind the development of Islamic managing an account in the MENA locale is just of preparatory nature.

To set up the system for investigation we begin with a few perceptions. In the first place, it has been watched on the planet that the nations where Islamic fund is developing was be those that are additionally seeing general advancement of their monetary divisions by and large on the other hand they as of now have a created monetary part. Subsequently the elements that are critical for general development of the fiscal part might additionally help the development of Islamic keeping money and account. Then again, this is not an inadequate explanation as there are numerous unique peculiarities of Islamic saving money that are not conceivable to become possibly the most important factor under the traditional saving money setup, i.e., accepted managing an account regulations and its strong institutional building design, which are focused around immaculate budgetary intermediation rationality.

Thus, we see that nations where administrative help exists for Islamic saving money (such as in the structure of separate permitting and administrative prerequisites, evasion of twofold levy, authorization for the Islamic banks to get included in exchanging and immediate financing and so on.) and where a level playing field is given, Islamic saving money is creating speedier. This is our second perception. Third, to roll out an improvement in the administrative environment a solid political was of the administration is a critical variable. Hence, it was be likely that the nations where the governments (or political framework) was be proactive to roll out an improvement towards Islamic money the Islamic managing an account was develop speedier than in the nations where the government was be apathetic to the idea or where it is disheartening it.

Fourth, Islamic saving money is developing due to its request by the general public. This interest additionally helps impacting the political was. The interest in financial sense is the capacity and eagerness of the people furthermore the corporate firms for using Islamic keeping money administrations. The interest for Islamic managing an account in a nation can’t basically be measured by the extent of Muslim populace in all out populace of that nation. Considering MENA area nations for sample, every one of these nations have a exceptionally high extent of Muslim populace yet varying levels of eagerness. For our dissection of drivers of Islamic fund in the MENA locale we joined the second and third variables into one and performed a relapse examination utilizing three elements, to be specific, general money related segment improvement, administrative backing and political was, and request for Islamic account.

We operationalize these with some substitute variables and assessed a stingy model given the constrained sum of information at hand. This model was be utilized just to find the relative essentialness of the above three variables for Islamic managing an account development in the locale, yet not in individual nations, by pooling the time-arrangement and the cross-segment information (Beck, Thorsten, Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda, 2010). The ward variable – development of Islamic saving money is measured here by two substitutes (i) proportion of stakes of normal Islamic banks to GDP, and (ii) degree of stores of normal Islamic banks to GDP. Every one of these variables was be taken as the ward variable, each one in turn, in two different relapses. Here the utilization of „average assets‟ also „average deposits‟ of Islamic banks for every nation for every year as opposed to the utilization of „total assets‟ and „total deposits‟ of Islamic banks is to control for contrasts in example size (number of banks) crosswise over nations. This is separated by GDP to control for nation level contrasts in the GDP.

Among the free variables, the proportion of expansive cash (M2) to GDP is utilized to substitute for general budgetary part development. Interest for Islamic account is measured by GDP for every capita duplicated by Islamic fund mindfulness which was be measured by the degree of number of news things relating to Islamic fund to aggregate number of news things on fund by and large.

Social Disclosure Impacts

The information on the amount of news things were assembled utilizing Google News web crawler. Islamic saving money in the MENA area has been a quickly developing part. As prove by information in the advantages, stores, and financing all developed quick in the area throughout 2006-2007 (Beck, Thorsten, Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda, 2010). Nevertheless, the development rate decreased in 2007-2008 period, which may be because of the thump on influence of the budgetary emergency. Even with this balance influence, the execution of Islamic managing an account division had been much superior to routine banks throughout that period. The unfavorable influence of the emergency overflowed to Islamic banks just in 2009.

To efficiently think about the execution of Islamic banks crosswise over nations a approach is formulated in this area whereby we think about the normal of key proportions of Islamic banks in one nation with the also arrived at the midpoint of key proportions of Islamic banks in alternate nations (Beck, Thorsten, Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda, 2010). This is, as though a normal (agent) Islamic bank in one nation was be contrasted and the normal (delegate) Islamic banks in other nations and also with the normal for MENA area. The key proportions chose for examination was be: return to value, return on possessions, holding use proportion, and working wage to possession proportion. The return to value (ROE) as measured by net benefit to complete value fluctuated fundamentally crosswise over Islamic banks in our test however in general remained high even throughout the worldwide fiscal emergency when the ordinary managing an account area universally was extremely influenced. For sample, for a normal Islamic bank in UAE throughout 2008 the ROE was over 15 percent, most elevated in the locale contrasted with different nations.

Throughout that year ROE for a normal Islamic bank in Bahrain was 7.2 percent, in Egypt about 0.1 percent, Jordan 14.4 percent, Kuwait 8.2 percent, Lebanon negative 9 percent, Qatar 11.9 percent, Saudi Arabia 10.7 percent, and Yemen 7 percent. The figures for Lebanon are an outlier in our specimen as the main Islamic bank there came into being in 2006 and it is experiencing a developmental stage (IRTI, 2009). However, the circumstances changed in the MENA region throughout 2009 when ROE of Islamic banks declined in generally nations. This shows authentic information on ROE, as measured by the degree of net benefit to aggregate value, for the years 2006 to 2008 for eight nations in the specimen and up to 2009 for five of them where information was accessible. The ROE in the MENA area shows a merging design from 2006 to 2008 crosswise over nations. This might be due to the directing influence of the fiscal emergency or it might reflect expanding coordination and rivalry over the nations. However, between 2008 and 2009 a veering pattern is very obvious with banks performing contrastingly crosswise over nations. Bahrain and Kuwait showed very negative ROE. While ROE figures likewise declined in other nations however they remained positive. On the opposite Islamic banks in Qatar saw an expand in ROE. Why the Islamic managing an account part performed so contrastingly crosswise over different nations throughout the distressing time in 2009 while they were uniting in execution prior? (IRTI, 2009)This is a profoundly paramount examination address that can shed light on vitality of different viewpoints for security and development of Islamic managing an account which requires a undeniable research in future. Based on from the earlier data, negative ROE in Bahrain can be ascribed to huge number of little keeps money with generally low capital base that diminish their ability to differentiate and additionally more level their limit to ingest credit misfortunes from soured murbaah and ijrah transactions. If there should be an occurrence of Kuwait the negative ROE, in spite of high promotion of banks, might be attributable to careless regulation as well as to the restricted household venture

open doors that headed banks to put in outside markets and over introduction to genuine bequest division. The better execution of UAE in 2009 contrasted with Bahrain and Kuwait may be because of solid liquidity backing gave by the Central Bank of UAE to its managing an account division including the Islamic banks throughout the emergency (IRTI, 2009). Various sorts of deliberations are placed set up in order to create the development capability of this area. Throughout the World Economic Forum on Middle-East and North Africa, held at Marrakech Morocco in 2010, worldwide and provincial pioneers perceived the capability of the region to turn into a developing business sector pioneer. “The Arab world has made much advancement,” said Lubna S. Olayan, Deputy Chairperson and Chief Executive Officer of Olayan Financing Company, “however further activity is obliged to close the sex crevice and lessen youth unemployment.” (2011) amazingly for the area, the danger of working together in Middle-East and North Africa has progressively gone up since the uprisings. According to Riccardo Fabiani the unverifiable political moves is the principle danger calculate in the area (Country Risk Services, 2011). Case in point, the temperamental political standpoint of Egypt had a frightful effect on the nation’s fleeting budgetary prospect (Beck, Thorsten, Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda, 2010).

It’s true GDP for the monetary year 2010/2011 is relied upon to abate to 2.7%, down from 5.1% in 2009/2010 (2011). The MENA is home to two separate sorts of economies: element driven economies, proficiency driven economies, as Jordan and Iran. Element determined economies are focused around a low wage incompetent work energy and common assets. In such economies, the social capitalist action in MENA speaks to 0.5% of the incipient entrepreneurial action (Global Entrepreneurship Monitor, 2009). On the other hand, in the productivity driven economies, competiveness is focused around a more gifted work power, a more effective generation, and an increase in item quality (CIBAFI, 2007). In these MENA economies, the social entrepreneurial movement speaks to 0.7% of the beginning entrepreneurial movement (GEM, 2009). The MENA area is additionally home to various sorts of social wanders. The most noticeable one being microfinance organizations. Be that as it may, as seen by Brandsma and Chaouali, regardless of the fact that micro financing organizations are extraordinarily display in Egypt; the nation alone records for 66% of the locale borrowers; the Egyptians limbs give credits to just 5% of the potential neighborhood request (2005). These numbers demonstrate that there is a crevice between the Offer and the Demand for this administration (Gulf One, 2008). Undoubtedly, while the genuine amounts of borrowers in the area approximates 112,000, specialists appraise the effort hole to be 4.5million. Similarly, the fiscal crevice for the area is evaluated at $1.4 billion. This number speaks to 0.5% of the absolute stakes of the banks of the area and short of what 1% of their aggregate loaning (2005). An alternate measurement of execution assessment is through analyzing the structure of wage and costs. Shows for chose nations the breakdown of aggregate wage into working and non-working wages and the breakdown of the complete salary into its uses: costs, procurements, and benefits before charges (Imam, Patrick and Kangni, 2010).

Categories of Islamic Banks

Islamic banks are categorized in more than 10 categories, however based on the paper three categories are going to be considered. The categories are based on the social and financial status of individuals. Saving and Credit banks, cooperative bank and Investment and development banks. This depands of the working salary and income of individuals (Iqbal, Munawar, Ausaf Ahmad and Tariqullah, 1998). The Proportion of networking salary in aggregate pay was most noteworthy for Saudi Arabia also most reduced for Bahrain among the analyzed nations. The operational costs as rate of salary were most noteworthy in Bahrain and least in Saudi Arabia (IRTI, 2009). This may be due to economies of scale coming about from for the most part bigger size Islamic banks in Saudi Arabia rather than more modest measured yet various Islamic banks in Bahrain. As for the procurements, these were the biggest rate of salary in UAE and most modest in Bahrain. These structures of salary and costs have suggestions for benefits. The before assessment benefits as percent of pay, on the normal, were most noteworthy in Saudi Arabia also most reduced in UAE.


Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions AAOIFI (2008),

Accounting, Auditing and Governance Standards for Islamic Financial Institutions

1429H – 2008.

Ali, Salman Syed (2009), Impact of Global Financial Crisis on Islamic Banking and

Finance and IDB‟s Response to Mitigate its Affects (mimeograph).

Beck, Thorsten, Asli Demirguc-Kunt and Ouarda Merrouche (2010), Islamic vs.

Conventional Banking: Business Model, Efficiency and Stability, World Bank Policy

Research Working Paper, WPS5446.

CIBAFI (2007), Islamic Finance in the GCC, CIBAFI Second Report.

Gulf One (2008), Research Bulletin, Volume 1, No. 12, December.

IBIS, Islamic Banks Information System, a data base provided by IRTI, available at

Imam, Patrick and Kangni Kpodar (2010), Islamic Banking: How Has it Diffused, IMF

Working Paper WP/10/195

Iqbal, Munawar, Ausaf Ahmad and Tariqullah Khan (1998), Challenges Facing Islamic

Banking, Occasional Paper No.1, Jeddah: Islamic Research and Training Institute.

IRTI (2009), Islamic Finance and Global Financial Stability, Report May 2009.